Friday, April 25, 2008

Debate: D'Souza vs. Hitchins

I was looking around on the website of Dinesh D'Souza, a Christian writer and speaker. On his website, he has a link to a debate he did against the prominent "new atheist", Christopher Hitchins. The topic of the debate was: "Is Christianity the Problem?"

These types of debates are very valuable for Christians because they require you to examine what it is that you believe, and to think critically and carefully about the points argued for and against your own position. You might find that you are uncomfortable listening to an atheist argue against your beliefs. This is a good thing. You need to know why you believe what you do. J.P. Moreland discusses this issue thoroughly in the "knowledge" portion of Kingdom Triangle. Do you really believe what you say you believe, or do you just say you do? If you don't have a good reason for believing something, then your belief really isn't a strong belief. But beliefs can be strengthened, Moreland argues. I think debates such as the one linked above are a great way to challenge our beliefs and spur us on to study and strengthen our position, while thoughtfully considering the opposition.

As you watch, I recommend you pay attention to the approach both men take to this debate. Keep an eye out for the strength of their reasoning and rationality. From what background are they presenting their arguments? Are they using good philosophical practices?


So, if you have a fast internet connection, go watch the debate.

No comments: